OK | RESET

SUCHEN

Alle Meldungen durchsuchen  


Das Prinzip von Entwicklung: Dynamik, nicht Statistik

Von der Ehrlichkeit gegenüber der Natur

Max Planck zum 150. Geburtstag

Überlegungen zur Klimahypothese:
Von der Physik der Atmosphäre aus gesehen, gibt es kein Klima. In der Atmosphäre spielt nur das Wetter eine Rolle.

FUSION


FUSION Nr 1/2008


FUSION Nr 2/2007

BÜCHER


Schiller-Institut: Die Weltlandbrücke wird Realität


Lyndon LaRouche: Die kommenden 50 Jahre

+++ 20. August 2009 +++

Cost effectiveness and Nazi Medecine,
the Chilling Example of Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel

In October 1939, Adolf Hitler issued a decree ordering the death of those who were considered “unworthy of life”, stating that patients considered incurable, be accorded a “mercy death”. The extermination started with the mentally ill, the terminally ill, invalids, and the disabled, and eventually spread to millions of Jews, Gypsies and other “undesirables”, who were worked to death or exterminated in concentration camps. This monstrous program was initially sold as a way of “easing the economic burden represented by people suffering from hereditary diseases”.

In today's debate about skyrocketing health care costs and health-care reform, the same type of “pragmatic” arguments are coming from top advisers in the Obama White House and the President himself – although couched in different terms.

A most egregious case is White House special health policy advisor Ezekiel Emanuel, who is also a member of the Federal Coordinating Council on Comparative Effectiveness Research, the 15 member panel that is to decide which medical care and medication will be permitted, and which will not. For those who might doubt the nazi parallels or the danger of systematic rationing of treatment, it is useful to consider what Dr Emanuel has written.

In the British medical journal Lancet, he elaborated a method for selecting which sections of the population should be denied health care in what order, in an article entitled, tellingly, "Principles for Allocation of Scarce Medical Interventions." That article was published on Jan. 31, 2009, which was 11 days after Barack Obama's inauguration. Then on March 19, Ezekiel Emanuel was appointed to the FCCCER – in spite of his well-documented positions on cutting costs for the most vulnerable sections of the population.

In the Lancet article, Dr. Emanuel describes his method of "Complete Lives System," saying it: "produces a priority curve on which individuals aged between roughly 15 and 40 years get the most substantial chance, whereas the youngest and oldest people get chances that are attenuated." This may be justified by public opinion, since "broad consensus favors adolescents over very young infants, and young adults over very elderly people." He goes on to explain that the "death of a 20-year-old woman is intuitively worse than that of a 2-month-old girl". And so on ad nauseam.

Dr. Emanuel, a bioethicist (i.e. eugenicist), claims his system is preferable to such inhuman accounting methods as Quality-Adjusted Life Years and Disability-Adjusted Life Years: “the complete lives system is least vulnerable to corruption. Age can be established quickly and accurately from identity documents.” (And the designated victims carted away, he could have added.)

Ezekiel Emanuel has also called for a reinterpretation of the physician's Hippocratic Oath, in order to take account of “costs” and “effect on others”. In an article in the Journal of the American Medical Assocation (June 18, 2008), he wrote: “At least 7 factors drive overuse [of medical care], 4 related to physicians and 3 related to patients. First, there is the matter of physician culture. Medical school education and postgraduate training emphasize thoroughness. When evaluating a patient, students, interns, and residents are trained to identify and praised for and graded on enumerating all possible diagnoses and tests that would confirm or exclude them.... In medical training, meticulousness, not effectiveness, is rewarded.

“This mentality carries over into practice. Peer recognition goes to the most thorough and aggressive physicians. The prudent physician is not deemed particularly competent, but rather inadequate. This culture is further reinforced by a unique understanding of professional obligations, specifically, the Hippocratic oath's admonition to 'use my power to help the sick to the best of my ability and judgment' as an imperative to do everything for the patient regardless of cost or effect on others." (emphasis added).

The potential savings from legalizing physician-assisted suicide has been a major area of interest for Ezekiel Emanuel. Fortunately for the terminally ill in over-crowded hospitals, he did, however, conclude in a 1998 article, that “Physician-assisted suicide is not likely to save substantial amounts of money in absolute or relative terms... for the nation as a whole.” So, at least he doesn't push that.

When Hitler set up his T4 program, to eliminate "useless eaters" from Germany's hospitals and nursing homes, he turned to a “non-political” body of medical experts to make the ugly decisions on who would die. Dr. Emanuel, in his 2008 book Healthcare, Guaranteed: A Simple, Secure Solution for America, called for phasing out Medicare, Medicaid, and the low-income children's health program SCHIP, and replacing them with government-paid private insurance. But the oversight on the approved payments, procedures, etc., he said, is to be made by an “independent” National Health Board, “to reduce political interference and allow the necessary tough choices to be made.” The Board should be nominated by the President, and confirmed by Congress, but otherwise not subject to objection from victims or voters, even being funded independently of Congressional appropriations.

It gets even worse, when one looks back to an essay co-published in the Hastings Center Report of Nov-Dec 1996) by Emanuel, in the context of so-called “academic” considerations. According to the “civic republican or deliberative democratic conception of the good”, he wrote, “services provided to individuals who are irreversibly prevented from being or becoming participating citizens are not basic and should not be guaranteed. An obvious example is not guaranteeing health services to patients with dementia.”

First exposed as “Dr. Death” by the LaRouche Political Action Committee, and then increasingly by others, Ezekiel Emanuel has made a vain attempt to convince the Washington Times that his thinking has changed. In an telephone interview from his vacation spot in Italy, Emanuel said that 20 years ago he thought rationing of care was an absolute necessity, and that there was a necessity to deny people care. But, now he has come to the conclusion that "if we got rid of unnecessary care, we would have absolutely no reason to even consider rationing except in a few cases.”

(Anton Chaitkin of Executive Intelligence Review confronted Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel with these accusations at an official hearing in Washington back on June 10. The video of his three minute intervention has been posted many times on youtube.com, and can be accessed by giving in search words “Chaitkin” and “Emanuel”.)



~ deutsch + english ~
Weltweit
Alle Themen

Weitere Meldungen

+++ 21. Dezember 2016 +++

Terror: Obama Issues Threats to Kill

On receiving the first reports, on Dec. 19, of the assassination of Russian ambassador Andrey Karlov in Turkey, American economist Lyndon LaRouche declared: “Put Obama on the list of suspects.”
... [weiter]

+++ 21. Dezember 2016 +++

Zepp-LaRouche Forderung für G-20-Gipfel: Marshallplan für den Nahen Osten und Afrika, statt Dekarbonisierung

In einem strategischen Überblick vom 17.12. befaßt sich Helga Zepp-LaRouche mit der Lage in Syrien nach der Befreiun... [weiter]

+++ 21. Dezember 2016 +++

Hillary Clintons Emails: Alles spricht für ein „Leak“, nicht für „Hacking“

Die Behauptung der CIA, „die Russen“ und Präsident Putin persönlich hätten die US-Wahl durch Computer-Hacking manipuliert, ist so grotesk, daß sogar andere Geheimdienste Bedenken anmeldeten. Der natio... [weiter]

+++ 21. Dezember 2016 +++

Hillary Clinton's Emails: All Signs Point to Leaking, Not Hacking

Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, CIA Director John Brennan, political figures in both parties, as well as the mainstream U.S. media have still not tired of blaming Hillary Clinton's loss of the presiden... [weiter]

+++ 18. Dezember 2016 +++

Zepp-LaRouche: Germany Must Shape the G20 Agenda with a Marshall Plan for Middle East and Africa, No “Decarbonization” Insanity

In a strategic overview article written Dec. 17, Helga Zepp-LaRouche, chairwoman of the international Schiller Institute, also takes up the issue of Syria. The government, with the support of Russia a... [weiter]

+++ 18. Dezember 2016 +++

Zepp-LaRouche: After the Liberation of Aleppo, A Large-Scale Reconstruction Plan Is Urgently Needed

In a strategic overview article written Dec. 17, Helga Zepp-LaRouche prominently takes up the issue of Syria, after the defeat of the jihadists in Aleppo. She notes that the government, with the suppo... [weiter]

+++ 14. Dezember 2016 +++

As Syrian Forces Empty Aleppo of Jihadists, Obama Moves to Arm Them

The Syrian Army has basically cleared the Aleppo pocket of remaining jihadist fighters, so that the largest city in Syria is now on the verge of being fully under the control of the government in Dama... [weiter]

+++ 14. Dezember 2016 +++

Tulsi Gabbard Introduces Bill to Stop President Obama from Arming the Jihad

President Obama issued a directive on Dec. 8, authorizing delivery of lethal weapons to “foreign forces, irregular forces, groups, or individuals engaged in supporting or facilitating ongoing U.S. mil... [weiter]

+++ 14. Dezember 2016 +++

Economy, Russia: European Leaders Cling to Their Failed Policies

The new dynamic supplanting the geopolitics of the trans-Atlantic world is very much centered on China, and is strongly supported by Russia, India, and a myriad of other developing countries in Asia, ... [weiter]

+++ 8. Dezember 2016 +++

Glass-Steagall Works in China, and Will Be Strengthened

China's banking system has, by some estimates, issued $20 trillion in credit for economic expansion since 2008. At the same time, it has kept the exposure to derivatives down to a very small amount, c... [weiter]

+++ 8. Dezember 2016 +++

Italian Referendum: Another Big Blow for the European Union

The smashing defeat of pro-EU oligarchies in the Italian constitutional referendum of Dec. 4 opens up a new phase in European politics and bears global implications. This is the third shock delivered ... [weiter]

+++ 1. Dezember 2016 +++

Sputnik Interviews Rep of Cheminade Campaign: “Why Fillon and Le Pen Mean Blood and Tears for France”

In an interview given to Sputnik on Nov. 29,the Editor in Chief of the French newspaper Nouvelle Solidarité, Christine Bierre, expressed the views of Presidential candidate Jacques Chemi... [weiter]

+++ 1. Dezember 2016 +++

François Fillon: A "Thatcherite" Who Calls for Dialogue with Russia

Former French Prime Minister Francois Fillon smashed his opponent in the Nov. 27 second round of the presidential primary organized by Les Républicains (right wing and center parties) taking 65.5% of ... [weiter]

Weiter zurückliegende Meldungen